, , , , , , ,

Although the continued strong job growth in most metals-using industries since the Trump tariffs was the most important takeaway from Friday’s latest monthly official U.S. jobs report (for August), it certainly wasn’t the only important manufacturing employment news. So here are some of the other highlights (or lowlights) of the Labor Department release worth noting.

As I wrote Friday, the 3,000 sequential drop in manufacturing’s payrolls in August was the sector’s first monthly dip since July, 2017. And worse, the revisions (which were weak for the entire economy as well), cut the estimates of July and August net jobs gains nearly in half.

As a result, whereas July’s year-on-year manufacturing jobs increase was previously pegged at 327,000, the newest estimate (which is still preliminary) is only 296,000. Yet it’s still the best such advance since May, 1995 (297,000), which ain’t beanbag. Less impressive, though, the August annual increase (which is also preliminary) was lower still (254,000). On the other hand, it still represented a major pickup from between the two previous Augusts (116,000).

The August monthly slip and the downward revisions also slowed manufacturing’s progress in accounting for a growing share of overall non-farm employment (the Labor Department’s U.S. jobs universe).

As of the July jobs report, this share had risen to 8.55 percent – a decided improvement from the 8.47 percent figure from July, 2017. But now the July, 2018 number has been downgraded to 8.53 percent, and August’s dropped to 8.52 percent. As a result, although manufacturing employment has still been growing faster than overall American employment during the Trump administration (in February, 2017 – the President’s first full month in office, it stood at 8.49 percent of non-farm jobs), the degree of out-performance is less than previously judged.

Over the longer term, manufacturing’s status as an employment laggard is much clearer. Since it hit its latest bottom, in February and March, 2010, domestic industry has regained 1.264 million (55.12 percent) of the 2.293 million net new jobs it had lost during the Great Recession and its aftermath. All the same, its payrolls are still 7.49 percent below where they were when the recession officially began, at the end of 2007.

By contrast, the private sector overall lost 8.785 million jobs from the recession’s onset through its employment bottom in February, 2010. Since then, employment has grown by 19.689 million. And there are now 9.40 percent more private sector jobs than there were at the end of 2007.

But although the August jobs report altered the recent manufacturing jobs story somewhat, the discouraging manufacturing wages story remained fully intact. On a sequential basis, pre-inflation wages for the overall private sector increased by 0.37 percent, versus 0.22 percent for manufacturing workers. And on an annual basis, such current dollar private sector pay rose 2.92 percent for the private sector (its best such performance since May, 2009), but only a 1.80 percent improvement for manufacturing workers (the best such performance since January).

In fact, since the current economic recovery began in mid-2009, pre-inflation manufacturing wages are up 17.64 percent. For the private sector overall, they’ve risen by 22.67 percent.

In inflation-adjusted terms, manufacturing’s wages performance during the recovery is even worse. The latest data go up only through July, but they show that, since mid-2009, real private sector wages have risen by 4.46 percent. The increase for manufacturing workers has been only 0.28 percent – less than one-fifteenth as fast.

Yet as suggested by these meager price-adjusted improvements, both the private sector overall and manufacturing have turned in dismal wage performances. In fact, both remain in real wage recessions – i.e., stretches of two straight quarters or more where hourly pay has declined on net. For the entire private sector, after-inflation wages are down by 0.09 percent since July, 2017. For manufacturing, they’re off by 0.19 percent since January, 2016.