(What’s Left of) Our Economy: Tariffs-Led Consumer Inflation Grows…from Non-Existent to Slight

Tags

aluminum, Bureau of Labor Statistics, China, consumer price inflation, consumer prices, core inflation, inflation, metals, metals tariffs, metals-using industries, steel, tariffs, Trade, tradewar, Trump, {What's Left of) Our Economy

After a several-month lapse, I finally had a chance to review in detail the latest batch of official U.S. consumer price data, which came out yesterday. The big takeaway seems as follows: Whereas through April there was no evidence that President Trump’s tariffs per se were pushing up consumer prices, now there’s some. But the evidence certainly doesn’t paint a picture of the American shopper’s living standards tumbling steeply because of Mr. Trump’s various trade wars.

As usual, let’s examine the metals-using industries, since the Trump tariffs on steel and aluminum have been in place for a relatively long period (April, 2018 was their first full month) and for reasons to be explained below, because it’s much easier to identify these sectors than those presumably impacted by the China tariffs.

The table below presents the relevant figures for major metals-using industries sequentially for the latest data month (June), since the duties’ onset, and year-on-year for the two latest data months. In addition, the results for control groups (like for overall core inflation, and for foods sometimes packaged in metal cans in their fresh forms):

                             May-June        Since April, 2018       y/y May           y/y June

core inflation:   +0.22 percent      +2.39 percent        +1.99 percent   +2.13 percent

fresh fruits         -1.67 percent      +0.31 percent        +1.85 percent   +0.87 percent

  & vegs:

fresh fruits:        -2.06 percent      -2.85 percent         -0.95 percent     -1.85 percent

fresh vegs:         -1.24 percent     +4.10 percent        +5.20 percent    +4.09 percent

processed          +0.39 percent     +1.61 percent        +1.28 percent    +1.70 percent

  fruits & vegs

canned fruits:     -0.38 percent     +4.47 percent        +4.04 percent    +3.93 percent

& vegs

canned fruits:     -0.09 percent     +2.11 percent        +1.00 percent    +2.02 percent

canned vegs:     +1.26 percent     +6.04 percent        +5.49 percent    +5.28 percent

soups:                +0.26 percent     +2.59 percent        +0.37 percent    +0.30 percent

malt bevgs          -0.62 percent     +1.77 percent        +0.84 percent    +1.84 percent

  at home:

alcoholic bevgs  +0.20 percent     +1.34 percent        +2.17 percent    +1.46 percent

  away from hom:

non-frozen, non- -0.21 percent     +1.96 percent        +3.09 percent    +3.03 percent

  carbonated non-

  alcoholic rinks

carbted drinks:     -1.95 percent    +3.33 percent        +5.75 percent    +2.71 percent

  juices & non-     -0.96 percent    +2.49 percent        +4.16 percent    +2.86 percent

  alcoholic drinks

new cars/trucks:  +0.17 percent    +1.13 percent        -1.61 percent    +0.74 percent

motor vehicle      +0.07 percent    +2.60 percent       +1.94 percent    +1.91 percent

  parts:

appliances:          +0.21 percent    +2.93 percent       +2.43 percent    +2.56 percent

major                   -1.40 percent    +3.95 percent        +3.80 percent    +2.94 percent

  appliances:

laundry                -0.70 percent    +4.00 percent        -1.55 percent      -3.98 percent

  equipment:

non-electric         +0.73 percent –   4.07 percent        -5.22 percent      -1.94 percent

  cookware & tableware:

tools, hardware,   +0.06 percent   +0.12 percent       +0.88 percent     +1.22 percent

  outdoor equipment:

The most revealing comparison is that between the post-tariffs (April, 2018) rate of core inflation (which excludes the historically volatile categories of food and energy) and the inflation rates for the metals-using sectors. And they show that for the 15 metals-using industries tracked, prices rose faster than core inflation in ten – a sign of tariff-led price-hiking.

At the same time, as previously noted, the figures for three of these 10 groups – soups, carbonated drinks, and juices and non-alcoholic drinks – need to be viewed cautiously, because their packages are hardly restricted to metals. Thus my conclusion that the tariff effects have been modest.

And another interesting conclusion emerging from these statistics: the price of laundry equipment is dropping dramatically after surging following the imposition in February, 2018 of a separate set of levies on large household clothes washers and driers. These prices are still way up (by 13.75 percent) since the tariffs began. But the May and June data show unusually rapid price drops. And these decreases are much greater than the slight reduction in these tariffs that began this year.

As for the China tariffs, definitive conclusions remain difficult to draw for several reasons. Chiefly, the first full data month for the relevant duties (for consumer products) is only last October. The goods on the U.S. Trade Representative’s list for those levies are categorized with a classification system different from that used by the Bureau of Labor Statistics in measuring inflation – so the match-ups are far from exact. And the scale of tariff price effects can differ dramatically from product to product because China’s presence in a particular market can vary so greatly.

Another complicating factor (though clearly trade war-related): Some of the China categories have also been affected by the metals tariffs (e.g., auto parts). Further, the appliance categories have been impacted by the separate household laundry equipment duties.

Nonetheless, here’s the China data for May-June, since last October, and year-on-year for this June and last June. As with the metals tariff table, they include figures for control categories like the core inflation rate:

                            May-June       Since Oct.    June y/y 2017-18     June y/y 2018-19

core inflation: +0.22 percent  +1.59 percent   +2.13 percent           +2.26 percent

food:                -0.02 percent   -0.12 percent   +1.43 percent           +1.91 percent

frozen/freeze-  -0.42 percent  +0.52 percent    -0.23 percent            -0.09 percent

  dried prepared foods:

fish/seafood:    -0.74 percent  +0.89 percent   +1.43 percent           +1.66 percent

processed fish/ -0.98 percent         0 percent   +0.39 percent            +2.13 percent

  seafood:

frozen fish/      -1.32 percent   -0.61 percent    -0.91 percent            +1.68 percent

  seafood:

fruits/vegs:      -1.24 percent   +0.03 percent   +0.25 percent             +1.04 percent

fresh fruits/    +1.67 percent    -0.63 percent   +0.62 percent             +0.87 percent

  vegetables:

fresh fruits:      -2.06 percent   -2.49 percent   +1.87 percent             -1.85 percent

fresh vegs:       -1.24 percent   +1.54 percent    -0.82 percent           +4.09 percent

processed        +0.39 percent   +2.49 percent    -1.04 percent           +1.70 percent

  fruits/vegs:

frozen fruits/   +1.84 percent   +0.54 percent    -3.88 percent           +0.24 percent

  vegetables:

non-carb/          -0.21 percent   +0.61 percent   -0.37 percent           +2.71 percent

  non-frozen juices/drinks:

personal care    -0.27 percent    -0.59 percent   -0.30 percent            -0.60 percent

  products:

household         -0.11 percent    +0.13 percent  -7.87 percent            -0.03 percent

  furnishings:

recreation         -0.34 percent     -2.49 percent   -8.22 percent           -5.60 percent

  goods:

men’s                -1.24 percent     -2.94 percent   -0.69 percent          +1.53 percent

  sportswear:

women’s           -2.01 percent     -1.25 percent   -1.33 percent           -0.03 percent

  sportswear

computers,        -1.91 percent    -4.09 percent    -3.70 percent          -5.86 percent

  peripherals, etc.:

window/floor    -1.19 percent    -5.03 percent   +0.43 percent          -2.75 percent

  coverings:

furniture &       +0.82 percent   +2.64 percent   +0.02 percent         +3.15 percent

  bedding:

appliances:       +0.21 percent     -0.37 percent  +1.15 percent         +2.56 percent

major                 -1.40 percent    +0.33 percent  +5.62 percent         +2.94 percent

  appliances:

laundry              -0.70 percent     -0.22 percent +13.12 percent         -3.98 percent

  equipment

misc                 +1.19 percent      -0.84 percent    -1.05 percent        +2.28 percent

  appliances:

non-electric      +0.73 percent      -2.78 percent    -2.64 percent         -1.94 percent

  cookware/tableware:

tools/                +0.06 percent     +1.27 percent    -0.74 percent          +1.06 percent

  hardware &

  outdoor equip:

household          -0.14 percent     +1.14 percent  +0.60 percent          +1.52 percent

  cleaning products:

televisions:        -1.23 percent    -14.25 percent  -19.09 percent        -19.65 percent

misc video         -1.98 percent      -1.19 percent    -2.53 percent          -2.17 percent

  equipment:

pets &               +0.08 percent     +2.72 percent   +0.67 percent         +2.84 percent

  pet products:

sporting           :+0.39 percent     +2.79 percent   +0.07 percent         + 0.66 percent

  goods:

photo equip       +0.24 percent     -2.04 percent    -6.29 percent          +2.72 percent

  & supplies:

sewing              +0.41 percent     +8.21 percent   +7.54 percent          +4.63 percent

  machines/

  fabrics:

motor               +0.14 percent      +2.09 percent   +0.29 percent          +1.91 percent

  vehicle parts:

tires:                 +0.15 percent     +2.09 percent     -1.56 percent          +2.03 percent

stationery/        +0.59 percent     +4.95 percent    +1.16 percent           -1.31 percent

  gift wrap:

Even given the above uncertainties, the bases for claims that the China levies are creating a tariff-mageddon for American consumers look awfully weak, though they’re not nonexistent. Chiefly, since the tariffs’ onset last October, only eight of the 30 affected products saw prices rising faster than core inflation.

At the same time, more product categories seem to be displaying such characteristics. This conclusion seems clear from the two sets of year-on-year statistics. Between June, 2017 and June, 2018, prices were stronger in only three of the 30 categories (including products for which prices were falling at a slower rate). Between the following Junes, their number grew to eight.

Similarly, forgetting about comparisons with the core, 23 of the 30 groups experienced higher inflation rates during the June, 2018-June, 2019 period (largely post-China tariffs) than during the June, 2017-June, 2018 period (entirely pre-China tariffs).

Of course, Mr. Trump’s trade policy, especially regarding China, has never been about economics alone. The administration has repeatedly emphasized that national security is at stake as well. But these new consumer price figures make clear that the economic costs paid by Americans have so far been meager. And especially with overall inflation so weak, they hardly look like reasons for the President to ease up on the trade front.

(What’s Left of) Our Economy: Signs That No Tariffs-Led Inflation is the New Norm

Tags

aluminum, Bureau of Labor Statistics, China, consumer price inflation, inflation, metals tariffs, steel, tariffs, Trade, {What's Left of) Our Economy

With inflation in the United States still running below the Federal Reserve’s target lately, it’s been difficult enough for tariff fear-mongers to claim that President Trump’s levies on metals and on many Chinese-made goods are setting prices throughout the economy – or even in directly affected sectors – on fire. Yesterday, with a new month’s worth of consumer price data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, it’s become practically hopeless.

In fact, the big takeaway is that these March data closely resemble February’s. The only significant evidence of steel and aluminum tariffs-led inflation is found in canned fruits and vegetables – where it’s far from airtight – and in large household appliances, which include large laundry machines which have faced their own additional set of tariffs since early 2018. When it comes to products impacted notably by the China tariffs, the price changes are once more all over the board – which strongly indicates that the tariffs themselves haven’t been in the inflation driver’s seat.

As usual, the first table in these monthly consumer inflation analyses presents the price changes for metals-using products. They deserve pride of place for now because they’ve been in effect for more than a year, and because it’s easy to identify metals-using products.

Before zeroing in on the canned stuff, it’s worth mentioning that I found one more data point yesterday morning – inflation numbers for laundry equipment specifically. Some of these products could be the machines used by commercial cleaning operations as opposed to households, but they do sharpen the picture some. In addition, keep in mind that, since so many of the products affected by the metals and China tariffs are food products, the “core inflation” control group figures I’m using measure price changes minus energy – as opposed to the most widely use core data, which strip out both food and energy.

But back to the steel- and aluminum-related figures: Here they are for the February-March, 2019 period (the latest monthly numbers), and for last April to the present (the stretch during which the metals tariffs have been in place), as well as the year-on-year numbers for last April and this March (which provide some indication of trends over time). As usual, the results for tariffs-affected products (e.g., canned foods) are presented along with those of control goods (e.g., non-canned foods) to glean further insights into the tariffs’ effects.

                                 Feb.-March      Since April      y/y April            y/y March

core inflation:        +0.17 percent   +1.93 percent   +2.01 percent   +2.05 percent

fresh fruits             +1.56 percent   +3.55 percent    -0.43 percent   +4.25 percent

& vegs:

fresh fruits:            +1.21 percent   +0.65 percent   +1.38 percent   +1.37 percent

fresh vegetables:    +1.97 percent   +6.98 percent   -2.50 percent   +7.66 percent

processed fruits      +1.57 percent   +1.68 percent   -0.44 percent   +2.72 percent

& vegs:

canned fruits          +1.74 percent    +5.20 percent   -0.14 percent   +6.01 percent

& vegs:

canned fruits:         +3.02 percent    +4.99 percent   -1.60 percent   +8.60 percent

canned vegs:          +1.26 percent    +4.63 percent  +1.00 percent   +5.04 percent

soups:                     -1.33 percent     -0.16 percent    -0.38 percent   +0.54 percent

malt beverages       -0.62 percent    +1.77 percent   +0.84 percent   +1.84 percent

at home:

alcoholic                +0.20 percent    +1.34 percent   +2.17 percent   +1.46 percent

beverages away:

non-frozen, non-    -0.15 percent    +3.30 percent    -0.52 percent    +3.03 percent

-carbonated non-

alcoholic drinks:

carbonated drinks: +0.69 percent    +5.44 percent   +0.04 percent    +5.44 percent

juices & non-         +0.02 percent    +4.17 percent    -0.26 percent    +4.01 percent

alcoholic drinks:

new cars/trucks:    +0.46 percent     +1.13 percent    -1.61 percent    +0.74 percent

motor vehicle        +0.25 percent     +2.08 percent    -0.74 percent    +1.79 percent

parts:

appliances:             -0.76 percent     +2.80 percent   +0.27 percent    +4.83 percent

major appliances:   -2.02 percent     +4.59 percent   +1.55 percent    +8.80 percent

laundry                   -1.02 percent    +0.65 percent  +10.00 percent    +2.80 percent

equipment:

non-electric            -0.76 percent      -0.59 percent    -1.45 percent     -1.56 percent

cookware & tableware:

tools, hardware,     -0.63 percent      +0.86 percent   +0.19 percent    +1.22 percent

outdoor equipment:

The various fruits and vegetables results make a reasonable case that companies in those sectors have been able to pass along some hefty price increases for canned products to consumers. Specifically, except for the April year-on-year changes, all of the figures for canned fruits and canned vegetables show considerably faster price increases than for fresh fruits and vegetables, and even for their processed counterparts (some of which go into frozen or jarred, not canned, products).

It’s true that fresh produce prices as a whole have generally been rising much faster than core prices. But in their canned form, their prices take another big jump up – strongly indicating that something about the canning matters greatly. Moreover, even though the inflation rate in fresh vegetables is leaving in the dust that for fresh fruits, the canning effect is very apparent for fruits as well, especially over time.

It’s also true that the canning effect is much less pronounced for other food groups – like soups and beverages. But here the data is less definitive, largely because these inflation figures also include products sold in forms other than metal cans. And as observed in previous posts, the markets for these products tend to differ significantly as well – which inevitably impacts pricing power.

Yet this March, a generalized “metals-effect” argument once more falls apart upon examining the price trends in non-food products, whether for motor vehicles and their parts; household cookware and tableware; and tools, hardware, and outdoor equipment. Obviously other developments, and perhaps many other developments are playing bigger roles.

The glaring exception is in those double-tariffed laundry machines. Even here, however, that new laundry equipment category I just found reveals major year-on-year price deceleration between last April (ten percent) and this March (2.80 percent). And the March monthly prices were weak across the board in appliances.

The China tariffs continue to present an even more complicated picture for at least three reasons. First, for the following consumer products, last October was the first full month they were in effect. Second, the goods on the U.S. Trade Representative’s list for those levies are categorized using the different classification system than that used by the Bureau of Labor Statistics to gauge prices. As a result, the match-ups are far from exact. And third, the China-specific price effects for different products can be differ dramatically – according to the scale of the Chinese presence in a particular product market.

Nonetheless, here’s the China data for February-March, since last October, and for October and March year-on-year.

                                   Feb.-March         Since Oct.        Oct. y/y           March y/y

core inflation:          +0.17 percent    +0.99 percent   +2.02 percent    +2.05 percent

food:                        +0.28 percent    +1.45 percent   +1.21 percent   +2.12 percent

frozen/freeze-          +1.18 percent     -0.72 percent    -0.46 percent    -0.59 percent

dried prepared  foods:

fish/seafood:             -1.04 percent     +0.79 percent   +2.82 percent  +2.70 percent

processed fish/          -0.51 percent     +0.40 percent   +1.46 percent  +2.76 percent

seafood:

frozen fish/seafood:  -0.46 percent    +0.78 percent    -0.15 percent   +3.29 percent

fruits/vegs:                +1.57 percent    +3.43 percent    -0.32 percent   +3.91 percent

fresh fruits/               +1.56 percent    +3.71 percent    -0.38 percent   +4.25 percent

vegetables:

fresh fruits:               +1.21 percent    +2.51 percent    -1.40 percent   +1.37 percent

fresh vegs:                +1.97 percent    +5.07 percent   +0.81 percent   +7.66 percent

processed                  +1.57 percent    +2.37 percent    -0.06 percent   +2.72 percent

fruits/vegs:

frozen fruits/vegs:    +0.76 percent   +0.25 percent     -2.72 percent   -1.26 percent

non-carbonated/        -0.15 percent   +1.91 percent     +1.23 percent  +3.03 percent

non-frozen juices/drinks:

personal care             -0.27 percent   +0.64 percent     +1.52 percent  +1.25 percent

products:

household                  -0.04 percent   +0.74 percent    +0.69 percent   +1.46 percent

furnishings:

recreation goods:       -0.74 percent   -1.55 percent     -3.51 percent    -7.28 percent

men’s sportswear:      -1.04 percent   -2.54 percent    +1.47 percent   +1.98 percent

women’s                   +2.90 percent   +0.35 percent     -5.08 percent   -1.55 percent

sportswear:

computers,               +0.54 percent    -1.17 percent     -4.09 percent   -3.30 percent

peripherals, etc.:

window/floor           +0.44 percent    -1.96 percent    +0.74 percent   -1.83 percent

coverings:

furniture &              +0.17 percent    +1.38 percent    +1.26 percent   +3.27 percent

bedding:

appliances:               -0.76 percent     -0.58 percent    +4.82 percent   +4.83 percent

major appliances:    -2.02 percent      -0.34 percent   +8.08 percent   +8.80 percent

laundry equipmt:     -1.02 percent     -5.05 percent  +10.00 percent   +8.76 percent

misc appliances:      -0.29 percent     -1.33 percent    +3.25 percent   +2.56 percent

non-electric             -0.76 percent     -0.49 percent     -0.51 percent    -1.56 percent

cookware/tableware

tools/hardware        -0.63 percent    +1.27 percent     +0.39 percent   +1.22 percent

& outdoor equipment:

household               +0.83 percent    +1.24 percent    +1.79 percent    +3.33 percent

cleaning products:

televisions:              -4.20 percent   -10.91 percent   -17.95 percent   -19.28 percent

misc video equip:    -0.03 percent    +4.41 percent     -3.87 percent    +1.79 percent

pets & pet               +0.26 percent    +1.76 percent    +0.91 percent    +2.81 percent

products:

sporting goods:      +1.00 percent    +3.04 percent    +1.71 percent    +0.25 percent

photo equipment     -0.05 percent    -1.29 percent      -4.94 percent    -5.70 percent

& supplies

sewing machines/   +2.51 percent +12.51 percent     -2.08 percent  +10.32 percent

fabrics:

motor vehicle          +0.25 percent   +1.27 percent    +1.25 percent    +1.79 percent

parts:

tires:                        +0.15 percent   +2.28 percent    +0.03 percent    +1.08 percent

stationery/               +0.28 percent   +4.53 percent     -6.48 percent     -0.01 percent

gift wrap:

Even in sectors with a prominent Chinese presence, like apparel of consumer electronics, any kind of price-hiking tariff effect is elusive, at very best. In fact, in virtually all the products below, inflation has been decidedly weaker than in the core control group, and deflation is apparent in many.

Comparing the two year-on-year figures does reveal some accelerating inflation (or weakening deflation). This is especially clear in the food-related categories (including the broad food control group) and in some non-food segments (like household furnishings, men’s and women’s sportswear, computers and peripherals, furniture and bedding, stationery, sewing machines and fabrics). But softening prices can be seen in recreational goods, sporting goods, personal care products, window and floor coverings, televisions, miscellaneous appliances, and several others.

Since these tariffs-related price data began coming in, I’ve been saying that although inflationary effects haven’t yet shown up, they could always appear in the coming months. Roughly a year after the metals tariffs have been in place, it’s now time to start suggesting that the no tariff-led inflation situation is becoming the New Norm.